I’ve been spelling out how I view the larger world, especially in terms of corrupted and corruptible institutions, but I figured I would address the objection of “how can you see the world this way and be responsible for the education of impressionable young people?”
It’s actually not that difficult.
For one, I never discuss specific politics in the classroom. My students never know who or what I vote for in any given election, nor do I discuss it with them. Why? Because it’s not their business or concern. We all had teachers who wore their political opinions on their sleeves. I have had colleagues through my 18 years in education who did the same.
I find it takes away from the classroom experience because all it ends up doing is providing confirmation bias for one group of students and giving license to another group not to pay any attention to what the instructor has to say on the actual subject, because “he believes X, Y, and Z on political issues A, B, and C,” thereby rendering (in their minds) invalid his actual expertise.
I prefer to keep them guessing. One of the most fun moments early in my teaching life was right before the 2004 election; one section of freshman boys spent an entire class period in early November debating whether I was voting for George W. Bush’s re-election or for John Kerry. They could never figure it out, and I liked it that way.
Which brings me to another point, and one that doesn’t get enough of a spotlight in our youth-worshipping culture: teenagers don’t know anything. Ok, that’s unfair – a few know some things, but I remember how I was when I was ages 13-17: I merely spouted off what I was hearing from my (liberal) parents and what they read and watched. Once I was old enough to realize I needed to form my own views of the world, it dawned on me that if I went into education (as I always wanted to do), arguing politics with teenagers was really just arguing with their parents, not them, regardless of which way they leaned on the spectrum. This has been borne out way too many times to be enumerated in my experience, and I believe leaving the politics at the door is the best way to be effective.
So how do I square my cynicism with teaching? Teaching theology, it’s actually simple. There are certain principles involved – one is faith in God, not in princes (Psalm 146). Another is the reminder that man does not live on bread alone (Matthew 4:4). A third is the Golden Rule (Matthew 7:12). A fourth one is the Greatest Commandment (Matthew 22:37-40), and the fifth is the New Commandment to “love ye one another, as I have loved you” (John 13:34). What all of these things remind us of is that life starts with ourselves and how we interact with God and neighbor. Other principles such as charity beginning at home and the lesson of the Parable of the Talents (Matthew 25) are included as guiding forces in the classroom.
A major problem in modern society is we are encouraged to be how Luke Skywalker was prior to becoming a Jedi – always looking ahead, never paying attention to where he was in the present. We tend to miss the fact that there are things we can do right in front of our own faces. Instead, we are encouraged to try and solve problems that no singular individual can possibly solve at a distance, and all that leads to is “virtue signaling” and an elevation of good intentions above all else, with the problem remaining.
Instead, I try to encourage thinking things through logically, knowing that students aren’t going to learn anything if I just spoonfeed them what I want them to think and say. I also try my best to get them to think and act locally – one’s neighbors will benefit so much more from acts of charity and goodwill. “Changing the world” is a foolhardy exercise, but it gets more attention and recognition. However, real change starts small and locally – one step at a time.
If you go back to my original post on my cynical thoughts (as well as the follow-up), I stressed that top-down solutions almost never work. It always begins with the little things. Do the little things, and the big things will follow.
However, it takes patience and a willingness to make mistakes. Difficult for a teenager, but a lesson well learned, and one that will help them make their place in the world and society better.